Before I ventured overseas
four years ago, I had certain preconceptions about Japan, and the
Japanese people. The first was that it is a hi-tech, industrialised
country. The second, that the people lack individuality like a kind
of "ant-hive" mentality. There is a degree of truth in
both of these assumptions. Yet closer scrutiny has revealed a more
complex picture.
There is undoubtedly a lot of new technology emerging from Japan.
Hi-tech industries such as robotics are the cornerstone of the economy.
On a domestic level, household appliances are usually quite hi-tech.
For example, it is common to have toilets with control panels. Sometimes
the toilet even has a handy built-in pregnancy detector. (No need
to splash out on expensive home testing kits). Despite gadgets such
as these making the place look quite modern, the psyche of the people
is distinctly old-fashioned.
In a wealthy country with cold winters, you would expect most people
to have centrally heated homes. The Japanese use kerosene heaters
which, apart from emitting toxic fumes, do a poor job of evenly
heating a room. (The heaters are, however, computerised with control
panels.)
Every so often they have to be turned off, and a window opened
to let out the harmful fumes. Of course, letting out the fumes also
lets out the heat. But this is OK, the philosophy being that it
is good to feel the seasons throughout the year. Thus in winter,
one should feel the cold. While this seems poetic, in practice it
can be rather uncomfortable.
The summer is hot and humid, with a mini rainy season from mid
June to mid July. Temperatures are commonly over thirty degrees.
While many homes have air-conditioning, almost all state schools
have none. Students and teachers have small towels which they use
to mop the sweat trickling down their faces while in class. Studying
in this intense heat and humidity is almost like a slow torture
for students.
In many schools there is also a rule that prohibits students from
drinking water in class, thus the students dehydrate in addition
to overheating. Again, an old way of thinking still prevails: Just
as it is good to feel the biting cold in winter, it's good to sweat
in summer; especially for the young who need to be toughened up.
Japan is a country in which old values such as these underpin every
aspect of day-to-day life.
Tokyo is a seemingly endless jungle of faceless concrete apartment
blocks, futurist glass and steel buildings, fizzing neon signs.
Large advertising screens adorn the sides of buildings, escalators
connect to walkways, and elevators announce the current floor in
a sexy female voice. It is a city that wants to be modern. Old buildings
are knocked down and replaced without hesitation. Shiny new shopping
complexes spring up overnight.
The face of Tokyo is having a constant lift, but a modern looking
city doesn't mean modern thinking people. One only has to look at
the female residents of Tokyo to see this. Most women embrace a
very feminine look; high-heals, designer brands, skirts etc. In-turn,
images of airbrushed females are used to advertise almost every
kind of product. The question is which came first, the chick or
the egg?
Feminism doesn't seem to have manifested in Japanese society as
it has in Britain. For example, the concept of sexual harassment
at work is relatively new. The bullet train is famous world over
for speed and efficiency, but a less publicised fact about Japan's
rail system is that some of Tokyo's subway lines have women only
carriages late at night to stop women from being harassed by drunken
business men. Statistically, it is one of the safest cities in the
world...unless you are a woman on a Friday night.
Another illustration of traditional values is that of the family.
Japanese children are often looked after by their grandparents who
live in the same house as the parents. Thus the mother has a source
of free child care. The down side of this is, (obviously), having
to live in the same house as your parents. (The couple normally
lives with the man's parents.) Moreover, the wife may have to wait
on her mother and father-in-law in return for the child care.
However, this old style living arrangement does incorporate the
elderly into society, and gives them a functional role in the family.
Also, as they grow older they have family around to care for them.
Recently though, this enlarged family unit is becoming less popular,
as younger couples choose to live together alone. Although attitudes
to women and the family are changing, Japan remains a very conservative
country.
The second of my assumptions was that the Japanese have an ant-hive
like mentality, i.e. all doing and thinking alike. This is true,
in that expressing the same opinion and agreeing with others is
a kind of social etiquette. Boldly stating one's own opinion as
different from others is generally frowned upon. The idea is that
agreeing with one another fosters social harmony in the office or
group. However, when in private, people are happy to voice idiosyncratic
opinions.
Equality is another important value in group situations. If a worker
goes on holiday, for example, she is expected to bring back a small
present for everyone in the office. Failing to give someone a gift,
or giving a more valuable gift to closer colleagues creates problems.
The concept of equality is another way of trying to create harmony
in group situations. Of course, there is favouritism between colleagues,
it just remains out of the working environment.
Society frowns upon the assertion of individuality, and this means
people can also appear very homogenous. Primary school children
march to school each morning with identical yellow school bags,
(the design stipulated by the school.) Fashion trends sweep across
the country like wild fire, and fizzle out in the blink of an eye.
The national penchant for fads is unfathomable. Take Para-Para dancing
for example: It entails groups of young people dancing in unison
to club music. Needless to say it was only popular for a very short
space of time, although a few mavericks still indulge.
Though great value is placed upon unity of appearance and opinions,
there is in reality a lot of independent thought going on, it is
just difficult to see. People with unorthodox beliefs or practices
tend to hide them away from public view. A good example of this
is the gay community. There are very few openly gay men and women
in Japan, compared with Western countries. Yet the few that I have
met assured me that there are many more, albeit, in the closet.
Though gay people in our own country don't have it easy, the social
taboo in Japan is even greater, due to the value placed on being
the same as others. Many people perceive America and the UK as having
unusually large gay populations, when in reality they are simply
unaware of all those in hiding in their own country.
Tokyo's music and fashion scene is another example of the growth
of individuality in a supposedly unified culture. Hip-hop, reggae,
trance, and many other styles of music are very popular, as are
the fashions that accompany them. American films and music especially,
have had a tremendous impact on Japan's youth culture.
Yet there are some unique styles originating from Tokyo's underground
scene. In the hip fashion district of Harajuku young people walk
around in frilly lace, knee length PVC boots, powdered white faces
with black crosses on their cheeks. Goth, fetish and anime influences
contribute to the look.
Though there are seeds of individual expression struggling to flourish,
they are scattered sparsely. As soon as an original idea emerges
it is latched on to and becomes commercialised, tamed and marketed.
The same could be said of our own pop culture with movements such
as punk and rave that start out with incredible creativity, stagnate,
and become staple fodder for the masses.
The advantage of the West's emphasis on individualism, however,
is that that people feel less inhibited to try something different,
thus new musical styles come about. The Japanese tend to stick to
established trends, or latch onto imported ones. The result is "J-Pop",
which is by and large, banal high speed rock which isn't even catchy.
Despite J-Pop there are some good smaller bands in the Japanese
music scene which never seem to make it big.
Japan is a country striving to establish a new national identity.
Many people really do want change, but they find it difficult to
personally initiate. The difficulty is rooted in the social taboo
against speaking one's mind. It is for this reason that old ways
have remained for so long. Group pressure prevents business men,
made to work twelve hours a day, from speaking out. It is the same
taboo against airing a problem in public that prevents many women
from speaking out about incidents of harassment.
The mass import of foreign culture can be seen as evidence of the
peoples' desire for change. Modern Hi-tech industries have nurtured
the economy and provided great material wealth, but have failed
to propagate spiritual development in people. Last year some 34,000
people took their own lives.
In my view, the suppression of individualism by the need to sustain
group harmony is detrimental to the nation's mental health. I am
sure many Japanese would agree with me...individually.  |