Strolling home from
the office today, I noticed my neighbor had erected a new Japanese
flag - the fourth on the street. Passing the junior high school
on my block, I heard the muffled notes of a piano and a loud chorus
of kids belting out the national anthem. Both right and left-wing
politicians are now lobbying for constitutional reforms to alter
Japan's official pacifist position. My students echo Tokyo Governor
Ishihara, by moaning about "dangerous foreigners" making
our streets unsafe for their children.
In an apparent manipulation of Article #9 of the national Constitution,
which renounces "the threat or use of force as means of settling
international disputes", the government has successfully deployed
troops in Iraq. Prime Minister Koizumi provokes anxiety and fury
in those who once suffered from Japanese military aggression, by
making bi-annual visits to Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo - a memorial
to the WWII leaders.
Aside from causing irreparable damage in bilateral relations with
other Asian nations, district courts in seven prefectures filed
lawsuits against the prime minister, arguing that visits by political
leaders violate the separation of state and religion. In defense,
he claims his visits were of a personal nature. Oddly, he signed
the shrine registry as "Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi"
and traveled there in an official car.
Although reminiscent of wartime aggression and an outdated Imperial
government, strict regulations for using the national anthem and
flag in school assemblies were imposed in Tokyo metropolitan schools
in October 2003. Met with such resistance from uncooperative, liberal
teachers, the school board began doling out punishments on March
30th, 2004.
To date, almost 300 teachers, and other educators in the Tokyo
area have been reprimanded, and some have even been docked pay for
declining to sing the anthem. Principals have been penalized for
misbehaving children who remain seated during the singing of "kimigayo"
a trend that seems to be spreading to other school boards in Japan.
Fukuoka Prefecture authorities have begun to survey schools, scrutinizing
the volume levels during the performance of the anthem and issuing
warnings to the teachers of the quieter children.
It seems that social divisions are being created by controversial
rules, and old-fashioned symbolism is only effective in rousing
negative sentiments. Cohesive nationalism cannot be accomplished
in this setting. Why not write a new national anthem, praising the
cultural richness of Japan?
Why adhere to rules that do nothing to promote a positive learning
environment? Less emphasis needs to be placed on forcibly restoring
'pride' and 'patriotism', the preliminary steps of a potentially
dangerous path.  |